The happy medium: Accessibility and aesthetics in website design

We explore the reasons for and methods of integrating both accessibility and aesthetics into digital experiences.
Written by
Nichola Hudson
Published on
February 29, 2024
The happy medium: Accessibility and aesthetics in website design

Designers are challenged to create websites that are pleasing to the eye and navigate smoothly for every user, including those with disabilities.  

The crux of the issue is whether achieving full accessibility negatively impacts a website’s design.  

This article aims to challenge the power dynamics at play here, proposing that a well-executed amalgamation of design and accessibility is not only possible but also important.   

Balancing inclusivity with aesthetic value

Inclusivity should not be regarded as a design constraint. Rather, it is an opportunity to enhance creativity, providing a novel direction for design interpretation.

Creating solutions that please both the eye and cater to a wider audience may offer fresh perspectives. It doesn't mean deploying large buttons, excessively minimalist designs or resorting to garish colours.

Instead, it's about navigation simplicity, colour contrast, legible fonts, and ensuring your site is user-friendly for all visitors, regardless of their physical capabilities.

Striking the balance: Accessibility and design aesthetics

Creating a fully accessible site doesn’t mean compromising on design. In fact, approaches that integrate accessibility can often result in cleaner, more intuitive and engaging designs.

While there's no one-size-fits-all approach, there are certain recommendations.  

Taking note of colours that retain contrast but aren’t loud, easy-to-read typefaces that are also tastefully modern, and intelligently structured layouts that consider accessible navigation without dominating the design are all worthwhile considerations.

Employing these sophisticated yet accessible methods provide a middle ground where aesthetics and accessibility can co-exist comfortably. 

When accessibility and aesthetics are thoughtfully integrated, they create a synergistic effect that can significantly enhance a website's commercial success.

This combination can lead to:

  • Wider Audience Reach: You tap into a larger market segment by accommodating users with diverse abilities.
  • Improved Search Engine Optimization (SEO): Accessible websites are often rewarded by search engines with higher rankings, leading to increased visibility.
  • Enhanced Brand Reputation: A commitment to inclusivity and design excellence can elevate a brand's standing in the eyes of consumers. 
  • Increased Conversion Rates: An accessible and aesthetically pleasing website can improve user satisfaction, increasing engagement and conversion rates. 

The crucial role of user experience (UX) in balancing accessibility and aesthetics

In the quest to marry accessibility with design aesthetics, User Experience (UX) plays a pivotal role.

UX is the lens through which users see and interact with your website, encompassing everything from usability to emotion and perception.

It's about understanding the user's journey from start to finish and optimizing it in an inclusive, efficient, and enjoyable way.  

Is there a magic bullet?

The search for a "magic bullet" in achieving the perfect balance between accessibility, aesthetics, and user experience is ongoing.

However, the closest solution is adopting a holistic UX design process that prioritizes empathy and inclusivity.

This involves:  

  • Continuous User Feedback: Engaging with diverse users early and often to gather insights and feedback can guide iterative design improvements.
  • Inclusive Design Principles: Applying principles that focus on the diversity of users and their different contexts or abilities can lead to more innovative and universally usable designs. 
  • Integrated Testing: Incorporating accessibility and usability testing throughout the design process ensures that both elements are not after thoughts but integral parts of the development life cycle.  

The business impact of accessibility

Accessibility is not merely a legal or ethical obligation; it's a powerful avenue for expanding market reach and enhancing user satisfaction.

Websites designed with accessibility in mind could rank better on search engines due to the inclusive nature of their content, it improves the UX of a site which aligns with search engines' goal to provide universally accessible information.

This inclusivity can lead to increased site visits, longer engagement times, and higher conversion rates, demonstrating a brand's commitment to all users' needs.

Wrapping up

In the end, we're not just designing for design's sake but for users. A website should be a welcoming, comfortable space for everyone, mirroring the plurality of the real world.  

Thus, the inclusion of accessibility shouldn't be viewed as a sacrifice in design but as an enhancement, an opportunity for innovative and inclusive user experience design.  

Both design and accessibility are fundamental in creating an environment that appeals visually and is universally navigable, ensuring that every interaction is intuitive and satisfying. 

This approach respects the diverse needs and preferences of all users and translates into a positive business impact by broadening audience reach, enhancing user satisfaction, and ultimately driving higher engagement and conversion rates.  

There is no doubt that achieving the happy medium between an aesthetically pleasing design and a fully accessible website is a challenging feat.

However, it is not an unattainable ideal. And so, we must not shy away from the challenge but instead embrace it, telling the world that they can find their place, their accessibility, on our websites.

That is the true beauty of website design.   

If you want to explore how your website can achieve this balance between aesthetics and accessibility, please contact us. Let’s create a universe of websites that is beautiful and inclusive to all. 

No items found.
No items found.
No items found.


Regular newsletter
Our latest thoughts, tips and exclusive interviews in your inbox every month.
You're subscribed!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Please check your email.